Under the Same Moon

2007 [SPANISH]

Adventure / Drama

4
Rotten Tomatoes Critics - Rotten 82% · 91 reviews
Rotten Tomatoes Audience - Upright 82% · 25K ratings
IMDb Rating 7.3/10 10 7834 7.8K

woman director

Plot summary

Tells the parallel stories of nine-year-old Carlitos and his mother, Rosario. In the hopes of providing a better life for her son, Rosario works illegally in the U.S. while her mother cares for Carlitos back in Mexico.

Director

Patricia Riggen Photo
Patricia Riggen

Top cast

María Rojo Photo
María Rojo as Reyna
Eugenio Derbez Photo
Eugenio Derbez as Enrique
Guillermo Ríos Photo
Guillermo Ríos as Guero
Adrian Alonso Photo
Adrian Alonso as Carlos Reyes 'Carlitos'
720p.WEB 1080p.WEB
1013.96 MB
1280*692
Spanish 2.0
NR
Subtitles es  
23.976 fps
1 hr 50 min
Seeds 1
1.84 GB
1916*1036
Spanish 2.0
NR
Subtitles es  
23.976 fps
1 hr 50 min
Seeds 5

Movie Reviews

Reviewed by secondtake 7 / 10

Blooming with surface emotions and a tough contemporary theme with roots...

Under the Same Moon (2007)This story is one that will feel too close to home to many viewers--immigrants of all kinds, and parents who have ever been separated from their kids. The emotional stakes get piled so high you know that it can't end in disaster (the audience would be angry), so you kind of wait to see how the inevitable gets worked out.What holds it completely together is the stellar acting of the lead boy, played by Adrian Alonso, with great support from his pretty but a bit restrained mother, played by Kate del Castillo. You can't help but feel for them, and the many hardships they encounter will move you right along with the events.Which is the only conspicuous problem with the movie--the hardships are endless and brutal and almost comically classic. I'm sure they're all true enough, and I'm sure there are even individuals who face all these things in one lifetime. But it all happens in a week as the days tick off one by one to the critical weekly phone call. It's too much, really, no matter how you cut it--unless you think of it as a kind of modern Grimm fairy tale. In those, terrible things happen to kids and yet there is a dramatic outcome you take in stride. The fact this is kind of knowingly over the top happens when our two leads come within feet of each other (in the sprawling city of Los Angeles) and don't know it. Could be, but it doesn't help any sense of realism.And yet it is filmed with an attention to small details, to making people reasonable (bad and good people both) and believable. That's eventually all backdrop to the tale, complete with wicked relatives, a knight in shining armor, and a couple of scofflaws who come to the rescue just in time.It'll make you cry, and you might get mad at being so manipulated. But I think it's worth it.
Reviewed by StevePulaski 6 / 10

Manipulation vs. honesty

Carlitos (Adrián Alonso) is nine years old and filled to the brim with spunk and cuteness. He is the ideal protagonist in a movie about immigration issues in America. His mother is Rosario (Kate del Castillo), an illegal immigrant working in Los Angeles while her son is stuck in Mexico. Every Sunday, religiously, she will call him from the same phone booth to send well wishes and sprinklings of optimism his way. Carlitos lives with his grandmother, who abruptly dies, sending the little tyke on a mission to find his mother in the city of Los Angeles. He evades border patrol, traffickers, and seedy neighborhoods all in the pursuit of love and affection.Under the Same Moon (La misma luna) is an independent movie dealing with a huge social-issue the way a Hollywood movie would. It milks all the sentiment and tears this story can produce in record time. It's the kind of easily-digestible American audiences can stomach while at the same time not feeling so guilty or too depressed.The issue of immigration and the fact that a countless number of families have been separated because of it is one that can be taken under the wing of cinema, if approached pragmatically and cautiously. Under the Same Moon goes for the easy-way-out, neglecting to humanize the issue but humanize a certain far-fetched, nearly unbelievable storyline, portraying many of the Mexican characters as punching bags and the whites as stuffy cads who do not respect anyone not in their social class. There's truth to both of those archetypes, but should a film attempting to look at the issue of immigration and its effects on people be settling for such perfunctory features? It's a blessing to say that Adrián Alonso is an audacious little lead for a film like this. I can forgive his placement more as an emotional cause-and-effect case for the fact that he handles heavy material extremely well. His illumination on screen carries the entire film in terms of the kind of vibe it sets off. In the later scenes, when he meets a certain figure who has been lacking in his life (I'm sure you can figure out who it is) is when a character begins to emerge. It's a character that isn't as naive or as clueless as we may've believed. It's a character with maybe a little less innocence than we previously thought.The take-away information from Under the Same Moon is the fact that kids of illegal parents have experienced a whirlwind of trouble, hardships, and disappointment in the first ten years of their life than privileged youths will likely experience in thirty. This is a gruelingly honest point that the film tries to make. I'm a fan of the message but not so much the delivery. I tire of a story that paints one side as blameless victims and the other as the enablers or the bystanders that refuse to step in even during the gloomiest times. It's this kind of painting in not just cinema but politics in general that is detrimental to the credibility of an issue. We must look at both sides of the argument. In this case, perhaps each party is a bit too oversimplified.Movies like Under the Same Moon provide audiences with a pleasant diversion and competent family entertainment. This is not a story that a strong political thesis can be extracted from. The film offers solid performances, a pleasant culture shock, a conservatively-paced story, and characters we at least want to see turn out well in some way or another. The film is just all too "nice" about everything and never really seems to up the courage and dive into deeper reasons for deeper problems. The talking points you're left with are ones usually taken in-context to newspaper articles or present issues in the field of the topic; not from the actual film.Starring: Adrián Alonso, Kate del Castillo, and Eugenio Derbez. Directed by: Patricia Riggen.
Reviewed by OxyEskimo 8 / 10

Fantastic! Definitely Worth Seeing!

I just saw this movie through the Los Angeles KCET Movies Series and it was absolutely fantastic! While the movie does contain a subtle political message, it is not meant to sway the audience in the illegal immigration debate. The story carries extraordinarily well with a subject as touchy as illegal immigration and cannot exist without it. Utilizing a theme of abandonment, the movie explores what it means to truly care for and cherish a loved one. With brilliant acting (Adrian Alonso is incredible!), fantastic direction, and a terrific screenplay, the movie is a wonderful, heartfelt journey that brings laughter, sadness, and a sincere sense of happiness into an enjoyable, movie-going experience.
Read more IMDb reviews

No comments yet

Be the first to leave a comment